Meta Settlements and the Absence of a Method
A list of settlement figures looks almost comically disparate, and speaks not to the difference in harms absorbed by each state but to the variance in legal proceedings. This is the peculiar lottery we have constructed around corporate harm. Even when billions of dollars change hands, we still lack a coherent account of what was lost, who bore the cost, and what it would take to repair the damage.
GDP Counts the Ambulance, Not the Injury
Our story of one imaginary plant and one imaginary accident is a parable. The parable about the factory sets aside that when the factory works well it emits fumes that, downwind, cause harms, and its water waste contains chemicals that seep into the ground. There’s no fireball, no line of ambulances, no cleanup crew in hazmat suits. The sick and the dead are even more invisible than those for the accident.
Unpriced Does Not Mean Unpaid
A cost excluded from one balance sheet will always appear on another. It appears in a household’s medical expenses, an insurer’s losses, a government’s adaptation budget, a farm’s diminished output, or infrastructure that must be repaired or replaced. The benefit and the harm may appear on entirely different ledgers, but that separation is an artifact of accounting, not reality. The costs were never separate. The accounting simply failed to connect them.
Measuring the Black Holes
Sagittarius A* is nobody's fault. There was no meeting at which it was approved (but that might make for a cool scene in a sci-fi movie). In contrast, each item and action that contributes to the externality crisis has human causes: an old industry whose practices were grandfathered in; a siting decision, a regulation written to protect some sector, a banker who chose to look the other way. But the good news from this: humans can comprehend and resolve what humans cause.
We All Live Downwind
We all live downwind. Literally, from a factory or a freeway shedding microplastics with every mile driven. Metaphorically, in a world shaped by the consequences of others — a warming climate, an emptying ocean, harms we inherit rather than choose. The costs are real; the accounting is incomplete.
And this is not a new observation, but it is only in the last century that economists have tried to account for it at all.